Editorial: Latest test scores show futility of throwing money at weak education reforms

Over the past four decades, according to a Cato Institute analysis, Nevada has increased K-12 public school funding by 80 percent per pupil, adjusted for inflation. During those four decades student test scores have actually fallen slightly.

Now another statistic has revealed the apparent futility of all that increased spending.

This past spring for the first time, all Nevada high school juniors were required to take the ACT college entrance exam. According to an Associated Press account, only 8 percent of those juniors are ready for college in the four major subject areas. The average score was 17.4 on a 36-point scale.

Seth Rau — policy director for Nevada Succeeds, an education advocacy organization — called the data depressing in an op-ed in the Las Vegas newspaper. He noted that 12 other states require all juniors to take the ACT, and Nevada’s average score was a full point-and-a-half below the next lowest state with mandatory testing, North Carolina. A score of 21.3 is considered college ready.

Rau said the data should be used as a base by which the education reforms passed by the 2015 Legislature at the behest of Gov. Brian Sandoval can be evaluated. Those reforms come with a price tag of more than a billion dollars.

“As reforms targeting middle schools and high schools — such as Zoom Schools, Victory Schools, and Career/Technical Education programs — come into place, the ACT should serve as a key accountability benchmark for progress in the short term,” Rau writes. “In the longer run, it will be a key measure of whether our early childhood interventions — such as third-grade retention and full-day Kindergarten — are paying dividends for the future of our state. If our students are not ready for college and/or careers in the future, then it will be clear that our investments in reform have not paid off as well as intended.”

The problem is Nevada has been pouring money into these special programs for decades instead of engaging in fundamental reforms such as incentive pay and tracking the progress of individual students and each teacher’s class results year over year.

Since 1990 Nevada has spent close to $2.5 billion on class-size reduction, but a 2001 report by the Nevada Legislative Counsel Bureau found that in many cases students in larger classes outperformed those in the smaller classes.

Most of those Zoom Schools and Victory Schools are in urban districts with large populations of students for which English is a second language.

Former Democratic Assemblywoman Lucy Flores, who pushed the 2013 law that ended high school proficiency exams as a requirement for graduation but mandated the ACT test, told the AP in response to the low ACT scores, “That’s shocking … and this is from someone who has spent years now diving into our educational system. … It’s a stark reminder that we’ve got a lot more work to do.”

Of the 2015 education funding increase, Flores remarked, “I think we’ve made a whole lot of progress. … I hope this serves as a very stark reminder that we have to keep our foot on the gas pedal. We have to make sure every last kid has the resources they need.”

Nevada has kept its foot on the gas pedal for decades with nothing to show for it except a steady decline.

It is past time for Nevada to stop wasting money and initiate real education reforms.

A version of this editorial appeared this past week in some of the Battle Born Media newspapers — The Ely Times, the Mesquite Local News, the Mineral County Independent-News, the Eureka Sentinel and the Lincoln County Record.

7 comments on “Editorial: Latest test scores show futility of throwing money at weak education reforms

  1. Mark Levin’s new book “Plunder and Deceit” has an excellent chapter on education, and what’s wrong with our current system…I highly recommend it!

  2. The class-size myth is universally unquestioned. It infuriates me to no end! Thanks Tom!

  3. Winston Smith says:

    Do kids study hard these days like we did back in ancient times if we wanted to go to college?

    O Priorities! Thou separator of men!

  4. […] mind that the state has increased education spending 80 percent per pupil, adjusted for inflation, during the past 40 years with no detectible effect on test […]

  5. […] education spending 80 percent per pupil, adjusted for inflation, over the past 40 years with no detectible effect on student test […]

  6. […] by 80 percent per pupil, adjusted for inflation, over the past four decades, during which student test scores have actually fallen […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s