Equal justice under the law?
Today Bunkerville rancher Cliven Bundy and sons Ryan and Ammon, as well as self-styled militia member Ryan Payne, go on trial in federal court in Las Vegas for charges stemming from the April 2014 armed standoff with BLM agents attempting to confiscate Bundy’s cattle for failure to pay grazing fees on public land. Charges include obstruction of justice, conspiracy, extortion, assault and impeding federal officers.
They have been jailed for nearly two years pending trial. The trial is expected to take months to complete. Six more defendants, including two more Bundy sons, Dave and Mel Bundy, is scheduled for 30 days after the current trial ends.
In an earlier trial defendants Ricky Lovelien of Oklahoma and Steven Stewart of Idaho were acquitted of all charges by a jury. That jury acquitted two others of many charges but could not reach a unanimous verdict on four counts against Eric Parker and two counts against Scott Drexler, both of Idaho. Parker’s attorney told The Associated Press that a juror told him that votes were 11-1 for acquittal on those six counts.
Parker and Drexler have since pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor and released for time served.
Internet blogger Peter Santilli entered a guilty plea to a conspiracy charge earlier this month and faces a potential six-year term.
Gerald “Jerry” DeLemus of New Hampshire pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit an offense against the U.S. and interstate travel in aid of extortion. He was sentenced to seven years in prison.
A jury convicted Gregory Burleson of Arizona of eight counts, including assault, threats, extortion, obstruction of justice, and multiple gun charges. He was sentenced to more than 68 years in federal prison. Todd Engel of Idaho was convicted by the same jury but apparently has not yet been sentenced but faces up to 30 years in prison.
The fate of those now on trial may depend largely upon who is picked as jurors. The judge in the case has ruled that the defendants may not argue that their actions were justified by the First Amendment right to free speech or their Second Amendment right to bear arms. She concluded, “The Court will not permit argument, evidence, or testimony regarding Defendants’ beliefs about the constitution as such beliefs are irrelevant and a possible jury nullification attempt.”
So far the Bunkerville prosecutions have not resulted in equal outcomes.
You are right. The outcome will totally depend on the jurors selected.
The government has spent millions of dollars and countless man hours on something that should never have happened.
Bundy is no hero and his disregard of the laws and regulations concerning grazing and permitting are neither admirable nor in my mind, defensible. But the Government’s hands are not clean here either. The over reaction and massive show of armed force by the Federal Government was something out of the pages of of the wild west.
You are correct on all counts. I might add to the Bundy side of the equation that, if he had paid his grazing fees and abided by the months BLM would have allowed him to graze, his cattle would have lost weight and the ranch gone out of business 20 years ago.
Ask the Hage and Fallini and Gardner ranching families what it cost to fight the feds in their rigged courts.
[…] and sons Ryan and Ammon, as well as self-styled militia member Ryan Payne, are being tried in federal court in Las Vegas for charges stemming from the April 2014 armed standoff with BLM […]