Judge sends Searchlight Wind farm project back to square one

A federal judge on Friday basically told the company that has been seeking to build a wind generation farm east of Searchlight and the federal land agencies trying to accommodate the project to start over and fix the flawed environmental analysis or abandon the project.

U.S. District Judge Miranda Du granted the plaintiffs’ request that Interior Department’s Record of Decision, Final Environmental Impact Statement, and the Biological Opinion be vacated because they fail to adequately address concerns about impacts on bald eagles, golden eagles, desert tortoises and migrating bats, but she refused to grant a permanent injunction.

Searchlight Wind, now a division of Apex Clean Energy, has been trying for at least seven years to gain government approval to place wind turbines on 19,000 acres of federal land — at the paltry price of $118 an acre — near Searchlight. The $300 million proposal was to erect 87 industrial-scale wind turbines that would be more than 400 feet tall and generate 200 megawatts of power.

Simulation of what windmills might look like east of Searchlight and near Lake Mohave, home to bald and golden eagle.

In her February order ordering Interior and Searchlight Wind review the project’s environmental impact, Judge Du pointed out the initial data used by the Bureau of Land Management found there were only three golden eagle nests within 10 miles of the proposed turbines. Subsequent surveys actually found 19 probable or confirmed golden eagle nests within five miles of the site, the judge wrote.

The BLM’s original study relied on data from Idaho. “In December 2012, however, researchers published a study addressing golden eagle home ranges and foraging distances in the Mojave Desert,” Judge Du writes. “The study shows larger home range sizes and foraging distances than those reported in the FEIS (Final Environmental Impact Statement). Taken together, this new information is sufficient to show significant environmental effects that Federal Defendants should consider in an SEIS (Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement).”

Du also told the BLM to re-evaluate its conclusions about the impact of the project on desert tortoises, especially the effects of blasting and noises of the turbines during operation.

In a press release at that time the conservation groups who filed the federal suit to block the project stated that a survey actually found 28 golden eagle nests within 10 miles of the project site and that a new study shows golden eagles in the Mojave Desert travel nearly 10 times as far from their nests to forage as previously thought.

The plaintiffs include Friends of Searchlight Desert and Mountains, Basin and Range Watch and individuals Judy Bundorf, Ellen Ross and Ronald Van Fleet Sr.

The original suit accused the Interior Department of acting in “a manner that is arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and contrary to law.”

So far as I can find, the project has yet to find a buyer for the electricity the project proposes to produce. Without a contracted buyer it is questionable whether the company will find it practical to continue to sink money into a project that might never get approved due to the environmental hurdles.

But the government has 60 days to appeal, though there would be no point if Apex doesn’t have the wherewithal. Also the wind production tax credit expired at the end of 2014 and Congress has yet to extend it.

Judy Bundorf, the lead plaintiff in the case, reacted by saying:

I’m thrilled that the people who live in and around Searchlight won’t have to deal with the impact of such a huge construction project and the noise and flashing lights 24/7 for 25 or 30 years after the project is built.

Equally important, the untouched desert and variety of desert wildlife, including birds, mammals, and reptiles, not to mention Joshua tree forests, deserve to be protected.

Further, the proximity of the proposed wind project to Lake Mead National Recreation Area, Spirit Mountain, and numerous wilderness areas makes it unsuitable for large-scale industrial development of any kind.

Du’s Friday ruling: 13-616 Order Granting Vacatur 10-30-15

Du’s February ruling: Opinion_on_Summary_Judgment_2-3-15


11 comments on “Judge sends Searchlight Wind farm project back to square one

  1. Steve says:

    They can build it on Harry’s old property now that he is out of the way…..

    I would rather see a molten salt plant in that valley than blowhard wind projects.

  2. Let’s see how the Tonopah plant works first.

  3. Steve says:

    You know they figured out the bird problem.

    Standby mode was focusing the mirrors just above the tower. The hot spot in the air attracted the birds. When focused on the tower no birds.
    Standby now spreads out the focal point so no bright spot of air exists, birds stopped flying in to the area. The same solution has been employed at Ivanpah.

    We are about to find out how it works, though I wonder why they plan to stop daily generation at midnight…it should be able to operate 24/7

  4. Yes, but that is only for standby. There still is a problem during operations.

    I don’t think the residual salt temperature would sustain 24 hours. Maybe they’ll know better once operational.

  5. Steve says:

    From what I read there have been zero bird deaths since they changed standby. Birds stay away when the towers are in in use.


  6. Steve says:

    I was never impressed with Ivanapah, it was never designed to include thermal storage.

    Molten salt has the potential to become cheaper than natural gas…at the expense of huge swaths of land. But it is the best idea so far.

  7. iShrug says:

    Then there is the small matter of a $0.135/kWh PPA that NVE has with Crescent Dunes. And this price is for starters.

  8. Steve says:

    That price is offset by NVE’s recent purchase of solar power for less than .4 cents pkwh and Switch contracting with NVE to pay exclusively for so called “green power” though I have no idea how they identify where each electron is coming from! It’s not like electrons have identifiers like packets on a lan.

  9. […] judge issued her ruling on Friday, a 4TH ST8 blog was posted Saturday, but I can find no other media coverage of this significant ruling at this […]

  10. […] District Court Judge Miranda Du basically told Searchlight Wind, now a division of Apex Clean Energy, to start over and fix its flawed […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s