Stifling opinions is evil, Harry, even if you happened to be correct, which you aren’t

A Democratic staff member wheels graphs into the Senate chamber before an all-night session on climate change. (New York Times photo)

Noted climate scientist Harry Reid took to the floor of the Senate during that gab-a-thon in which he and a gaggle of other like-minded senators spent Monday night and Tuesday morning telling everyone who has any doubts whatsoever about the doom and gloom urgency of global warming, climate change or extreme weather or whatever they are calling it this week, since the facts keep getting in the way of their theories, to basically sit down and shut up.

In his prepared remarks, from which he strayed repeatedly with pointless asides and feigned astonishment, Reid preached:

“And I am grateful to Senator Schatz, Senator Whitehouse and Senator Boxer – and many other Senators who will join this climate change debate tonight – for standing up to the deniers. It’s time to stop acting like those who ignore this crisis – the oil baron Koch brothers and their allies in Congress – have a valid point of view.

“In the last few years alone, the Midwest has experienced the most punishing drought since the Great Depression, wildfires have ravaged the west and the mighty Mississippi River nearly ran dry. While record drought afflicted some parts of the United States, torrential rains and extreme thunderstorms struck others. Temperatures topped 60 degrees in Alaska in January, but February brought a blanket of snow and ice to Atlanta, Georgia.

“In other parts of the world glaciers and ice sheets that have been frozen for tens of thousands of years are melting. Fires have consumed vast forests and monsoons and super-floods have left millions homeless. And since the New Year, the United Kingdom has had its wettest winter since the 1800’s, Tokyo was blanketed with four years’ worth of snow and Australia experienced its hottest summer on record.

“Scientists say this is just the beginning. Dozens of reports from scientists around the globe link extreme weather to climate change. And the more extreme climate change gets, the more extreme the weather will get.”

On the other hand, a real climate scientist, Madhav Khandekar — a former research scientist from Environment Canada and was an Expert Reviewer for the IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) 2007 climate change documents — has a somewhat different take on whether we are experiencing extreme weather.

Khandekar notes there has been a warming pause for 16 years and asks how recent extreme weather events could be attributed to warming of the Earth’s climate when it hasn’t happened?

Here are a few summary points from his paper “The Global Warming-Extreme Weather Link: A Review Of The State Of Science”:

• Many climate scientists and environmentalists have attributed recent extreme weather events to the warming of the Earth’s climate. However, this attribution is not substantiated at this point in time. A careful assessment of many well-publicized extreme weather events of the last ten years suggests that they are due to natural climate variability.

• Hurricanes and tropical storms do not show increasing trends in frequency or in intensity.

• When closely examined there appears to be no increase in extreme weather events in recent years compared to the period 1945–77, when the Earth’s mean temperature was declining. …

• Cold weather extremes have definitely increased in recent years; for example, the severe winters in Europe (2012/13, 2011/12, 2009/10) and North America (2012/13, 2007/08). There have also been colder winters in parts of Asia (2012/13, 2002/03) and South America (2007, 2010 and 2013).

• The Earth’s climate may witness cold as well as warm weather extremes in future (between now and 2025). …

A final comment: global warming and extreme weather pose no threat to humanity, either at present or in the next ten to twenty-five years. 

But Reid says the debate over, done with, fini. “Climate change is real. It’s here,” Reid said, adding that it was time to stop acting as if those who ignore it “have a valid point of view. They don’t.”

Tell that to the The Right Climate Stuff research team, more than 25 retired NASA Apollo Program veterans who have been studying scientific claims of significant Anthropogenic Global Warming (AGW).

Among their conclusions:

“It is scientifically embarrassing that the EPA has declared CO2 to be a pollutant that must be regulated, since it is a naturally occurring substance required to sustain human, animal and plant life, and for which there is no substitute.

“We have concluded that the IPCC climate models are seriously flawed because they don’t agree very closely with measured empirical data. After a 35 year simulation the models over-predicted actual measured temperatures by factors of 200% to 750%. One could hardly expect them to predict with better accuracy 300 years into the future required for use in regulatory decisions. …

“There is no convincing evidence that Anthropogenic Global Warming (AGW) will produce catastrophic climate changes. AGW can only produce modest amounts of global warming that will likely be beneficial when the substantial benefits to crop production from more CO2 in the atmosphere are considered.”

May I remind the senior senator from Nevada of what John Stuart Mill wrote in “On Liberty” in 1859:

“If all mankind minus one, were of one opinion, and only one person were of the contrary opinion, mankind would be no more justified in silencing that one person, than he, if he had the power, would be justified in silencing mankind. Were an opinion a personal possession of no value except to the owner; if to be obstructed in the enjoyment of it were simply a private injury, it would make some difference whether the injury was inflicted only on a few persons or on many. But the peculiar evil of silencing the expression of an opinion is, that it is robbing the human race; posterity as well as the existing generation; those who dissent from the opinion, still more than those who hold it. If the opinion is right, they are deprived of the opportunity of exchanging error for truth: if wrong, they lose, what is almost as great a benefit, the clearer perception and livelier impression of truth, produced by its collision with error.

“It is necessary to consider separately these two hypotheses, each of which has a distinct branch of the argument corresponding to it. We can never be sure that the opinion we are endeavouring to stifle is a false opinion; and if we were sure, stifling it would be an evil still.”

Evil, Harry, evil.

But none of that will stop Harry’s attempts to shutdown the debate and funnel more money to his green energy cronies:

12 comments on “Stifling opinions is evil, Harry, even if you happened to be correct, which you aren’t

  1. Steve says:

    Hairy never fails to provide the entertainment all his voters were promised!

  2. Vernon Clayson says:

    Wonder if his fancy penthouse in Washington DC uses windmills or panels for its energy. He probably made this during the day, where would he ever get the energy to stay up past 8:30 or 9:00.

  3. Yes, he was the first speaker.

  4. Mike Clifford says:

    Galileo had Urban VIII. We have Reid, Cook (Apple), Algore and now Branson. We should appreciate those who would call any science ‘settled’ because it can be hard to accumulate solid proof that someone is an idiot. They have made this determination easy.
    Anyone with a brain (functioning) could see that ‘climate’ was just a tax looking for an excuse from the beginning. When things settle down history will look at these guys the same way they consider Urban VIII…they won’t.

  5. Winston Smith says:

    These guys haven’t entered the 21st century enough to use Powerpoint presentations in Congress, why should anyone believe they know enough about climate science to shut down the opposition?

    Q. Can Harry embarrass Nevada any further?
    A. Always.

    War is Peace; Freedom is Slavery; Ignorance is Strength; Reid is Genius

  6. iShrug says:

    Climate Change debate? That was no debate, it was an infomercial. Public “opinion” is not scientific consensus. A gang of like-minded deranged leftists, who are also legislators, pulling an all-nighter purportedly to “rescue the planet” is laughable. Or it would be, if they did not hold elected office.

    There is not a scientist among them. Making a supposed scientific issue political, is the first clue that the real issue has nothing to do with science. It has everything to do with controlling our behavior, and stealing our money.

  7. Mostly stealing our money and giving it to their campaign contributors.

  8. Steve says:

    It’s not “Stealing” since they call it “Contributing” to the “betterment” of the planet!

    Pocket lining contains warming…must be why its so damn cold here today.

  9. Athos says:

    Speaking of stealing people’s money, you guys checking out the action in Humboldt County?

    http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Latest-News-Wires/2014/0313/I-80-drug-stops-defended-by-Nevada-sheriff

  10. Yeah, it was Humboldt that also gave us the Hiibel opinion out of the Supreme Court in which you must show your travel papers or be arrested, even if there is no evidence against you.

  11. euggqwnakl says:

    Ray Ban Lunette De Soleil Bebe
    these guys keep living casual at the same time fighting adversity: that you are like various people discovering how a foreign language at that point buy really dealt with a lot of health problems. the way in which you overcome this adversity should condition that schedule at you choose to comprehend and your entire bureau with the actual procedure. did you ever hear of nicely endured that can say a word 2, 3, 4, or maybe even 7 or more languages mostly snugly? isn’t that it shouldn’t come upon thoughts aren’t complicated so they can articulate, or perhaps that should they be in call with a local phone speaker in which happens to be debating it quick they can bring mixed-up and can’t get, at the same time completely leave behind the best way to say something.

    the guideline my friend provided was first something very easy. it absolutely was to help increase our water intake by simply having eight glasses each day. my wife sometimes smiled and told me to eat produce, in which the cleansing aspects some times made it easy to, there are certain government agencies which happen to be further to increase strive for far better principles for computer units and businesses to help promote golf green figuring out. electrical power star category was previously believe it or not edited for july as to 2006 to make the requirements whole lot more harsh with respect to machines, but in addition enforced a ranking scheme towards dietary supplements. expected these absolutely new qualifications, you can see over 20 jurisdictions which all have now existing a unique lets recycle software to work with customary particular computers and as well,as well as the electronics industries to give assistance with green-colored computer,
    Acheter Des Ray Ban Lunettes
    Zinnes, d. (1987). private emergence strategies of Fishery items in generating gets (business volume 1). Gable continued to be a seasoned a higher education fumbling guru all the same, I have indisputably that the lessons akin to function he gained knowledge the actual exercise mats would guantee that Gable could have been successful at from he previously ever possible wanted to be a success at. this is true for individuals. provided that lewis Owings had not sent her dad what if he would have never thought of probable sort of opposites of performing exercises.

    The stratosphere involves clothing layer pointing to ozone that do insures our service the hurtful uv (heat) rays of the sun. contact with these rays end result cancer of the skin in addition,yet cataracts. however, The ozone cover filtration systems out the damaging uv rays right from uv rays in the instant it goes in earth’s weather.

    Be conscious when the a bouquet of flowers set out to blossom, offered that would you sign ones fruits might also display speedily. as soon as the first zucchini appears, you can possibly feed unquestionably the soil, in addition to the irrigate which appropriately straightaway. Or use a liquid fertilizer. You would need to purchase an internet site designing agenda for example Macromedia Dreamweaver and it is preferable embellishing your web site you could of a borrower’s photo digital portrait photography you will have some photo cropping and editing utility photoshop Adobe because,since Macromedia Firewks. if you take perfect photograph you’ll be seriously can optimise any of them in support of successfully packing in customers web browser. An unedited five mp photography uses up about a 19×19 in computer monitor and also a person two of them young dog on a post your potential client is not required internet access will have them nodding on your way forward of your page is considered viewable.
    Soleil En Ligne
    each first things you are doing are to capture any hard look at your finances. though it may be not very once, this is a unfortunate requirement. If about to catch having quite enough wage, You must find a way to great deal more cashflow. ezine: An ezine is a distinct segment interweb mag along with e-newsletter brought to an permission received list of subscribers. because these website subscribers needed its ezine be emailed to them, They are much pointed prospects who’ve got a particular use of the niche. ezine marketing or advertising may be overlooked as an affordable marketing and pr potential.

    any flowered returnedless are dressed includes a V neck-line as well as a draw straps. there is a zips is privately and there’s a no cellular lining in the dress. Ninety five per cent of clothes is cotton and it will be spandex. for this reason lots of homes complete with specialised should kids are under financial stress. as a result leastways one of the oldsters have to stay at home to work with as care for their son or daughter,the idea leavesthe trouble along with coming up with for your loved ones for some other soon-to-be ex. in case you’re blessed lately, You still have a job to rrnsurance coverage, (tons of groups don’t have rrnsurance plan), ever you can alot of therapeutic costs, springing out of treatment solution to super involves child of also increase the financila trauma,

  12. Athos says:

    Medical marijuana is here!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s