Supreme Court opinion tells Nevada judges to stop dabbling in campaign speech

A Monday Supreme Court opinion should send a message to Nevada judges. The court reversed and remanded a case out of Ohio that involved a law making it a crime for any person to “[p]ost, publish, circulate, distribute, or otherwise disseminate a false statement concerning a candidate, either knowing the same to be false or with reckless disregard of whether it was false or not” during the course of a political campaign.

Recently a Nevada judge forced a state Senate candidate in the Republican primary to stop running a television commercial saying his opponent was a supporter of Harry Reid.

A group called the Susan B. Anthony List attempted to erect a billboard in Ohio during the 2010 election season criticizing Rep. Steve Driehaus for voting for ObamaCare and thus supporting taxpayer-funded abortion. Driehaus got the Ohio Elections Commission to threaten the billboard company and the billboard was never posted.

Susan B. Anthony List sued saying the law abridged its First Amendment rights.

Writing the high court’s unanimous opinion, Justice Clarence Thomas said a “Commission panel here already found probable cause to believe that SBA (Susan B. Anthony) violated the statute when it stated that Driehaus had supported ‘taxpayer-funded abortion’ — the same sort of statement petitioners plan to disseminate in the future. Under these circumstances, we have no difficulty concluding that petitioners’ intended speech is ‘arguably proscribed’ by the law.”

Bill Raggio, center, was a Republican for Reid and was supported in his bid to retain a Republican leadership position by Ben Kieckhefer. (Sun file photo)

Considering ObamaCare dictates the coverage of abortifacients, the statement about tax-payer funded abortion might well be considered true by many.

Just as Nevada state Senate candidate Gary Schmidt’s claims about opponent Ben Kieckhefer were not proven untrue merely by the absence of his name on a list of Republicans for Reid. No one has found any evidence he supported Reid’s opponent, while he told a newspaper reporter he intended to support Reid backer Bill Raggio’s bid to retain a Republican leadership position.

But the judge in the case wrote, “Ben Kieckhefer is likely to suffer irreparable injury to his career and reputation from defendant’s television advertisements.” Being associated with our senior U.S. senator can do that.

Truth in an election campaign is not something for a commission or a judge to decide. That is for the voters to determine. There may yet be further court proceedings in this matter.

Justice Thomas also noted:

“The burdens that Commission proceedings can impose on electoral speech are of particular concern here. As the Ohio Attorney General himself notes, the ‘practical effect’ of the Ohio false statement scheme is ‘to permit a private complainant … to gain a campaign advantage without ever having to prove the falsity of a statement.’ … ‘[C]omplainants may time their submissions to achieve maximum disruption of their political opponents while calculating that an ultimate decision on the merits will be deferred until after the relevant election.’ … Moreover, the target of a false statement complaint may be forced to divert significant time and resources to hire legal counsel and respond to discovery requests in the crucial days leading up to an election. And where, as here, a Commission panel issues a preelection probable-cause finding, ‘such a determination itself may be viewed [by the electorate] as a sanction by theState.’”

Driehaus lost. Kieckhefer won.

About these ads

12 comments on “Supreme Court opinion tells Nevada judges to stop dabbling in campaign speech

  1. Vernon Clayson says:

    I get it, chances are good the members of the Supreme Court got a laugh that anyone would say someone was a friend of Harry Reid, surely they would have asked for a definition of “friend” before proceeding.

  2. Rincon says:

    I would much rather have these kinds of cases decided by a jury rather than a judge.

  3. Steve says:

    I would much rather have these cases solved by the voters than the judiciary.

    Lies and mudslinging are very telling…about the originator.

  4. Nyp says:

    “Captured Alleged Benghazi Ringleader Was Reportedly Responding To The Anti-Islam Video”

  5. Nyp says:

    “An earlier demonstration venting anger over the video outside the American Embassy in Cairo had culminated in a breach of its walls, and it dominated Arab news coverage. Mr. Abu Khattala told both fellow Islamist fighters and others that the attack in Benghazi was retaliation for the same insulting video, according to people who heard him.”

    Why is he covering up for Obama??

  6. NYT covering their asses with the same bunch of bogus sources from their last story blaming the video.

  7. Nyp says:

    Yeah. It’s all a conspiracy. The press is part of it.

  8. Steve says:

    NYT is covering up their own bogus words Nyp. No conspiracy here. Just blatant errors in research on their part from the very start.

  9. Nyp says:

    Because if there is one journalistic institution that lacks integrity, it’s the New York Times.

  10. Steve says:

    They are the leader!

  11. nyp says:

    Looks like we had another Second Amendment episode in California over the weekend. A patriot shot a BLM ranger and a California highway patrolman.
    http://talkingpointsmemo.com/livewire/blm-shooting-nevada-county-california

  12. Steve says:

    Why don’t you ever post or talk about THESE stories?

    http://myfox8.com/2014/06/10/dad-shoots-kills-man-who-held-gun-to-teen-daughter/

    These are REAL second amendment actions.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s