Newspaper column: Judge’s ruling last straw for water grab

This past week’s ruling by a state judge is doubtlessly the last straw for an already moribund attempt by Las Vegas to expropriate groundwater from Lincoln and White Pine counties.

Though the Southern Nevada Water Authority tried to spin the outcome as a win, because the judge did affirm Las Vegas needs the water and State Engineer Jason King has the authority to approve the transfer, restrictions imposed by Senior Judge Robert Estes make such a transfer highly unlikely, as related in this week’s newspaper column, available online at The Ely Times and the Elko Daily Free Press.

Farmers irrigate crops. (Photo by Kristi Fillman at GBWN)

King in March 2012 had approved the transfer of 84,000 acre-feet of water from Spring, Cave, Dry Lake and Delamar valleys — likely the largest interbasin water transfer in U.S. history. Las Vegas water utilities first applied for that unappropriated groundwater in 1989. The Engineer’s approval prompted a lawsuit from the Great Basin Water Network (GBWN) and others.

In his ruling Judge Estes repeatedly called the plans for monitoring, mitigating and managing (MMM) flawed and the water transfer plan “arbitrary and capricious.”

“There are no objective standards to determine when mitigation will be required and implemented,” the judge wrote. “The Engineer has listed what mitigation efforts can possibly be made, i.e., stop pumping, modifying pumping, change location of pumps, drill new wells … but does not cite objective standards of when mitigation is necessary.”

Judge Estes concluded unambiguously that if “it is premature to set triggers and thresholds, it is premature to grant water rights.” He remanded the Engineer’s rulings for recalculation of water availability and further studies.

Abby Johnson, president of the GBWN, reacted to the Estes opinion by saying, “This decision should send a clear message to SNWA and Nevada leaders that this project is doomed to fail and should be cancelled now in order to save Las Vegas ratepayers and Nevada taxpayers billions of wasted dollars.”

If nothing else, the Estes ruling is almost certain to reduce the amount of water Las Vegas could tap from its northern neighbors, making that water even more costly per gallon.

study for the water authority by Hobbs, Ong & Associates of Las Vegas found that Las Vegas water rates would have to triple to pay for the project.

The judge’s mandates and the costs combine to make this water grab extremely doubtful, no matter how thirsty Las Vegas gets.

Opinion of Judge Estes

Read the entire column at the Ely or Elko site.

About these ads

7 comments on “Newspaper column: Judge’s ruling last straw for water grab

  1. The state water engineer could easily be bought (he needs money for the expensive Christmas shopping season). We in Las Vegas need to seriously conserve water. The mega resorts ought to require guest to take shower in pair..lol

  2. Steve says:

    I wonder if we have reached the point Clark County will be forced to accept the fact that growth is forced to end due to water limitations.

  3. we don’t need anymore growth for now; lets get the quality of life up first (growth means more non -citizens coming here illegally at the urging of the Democratic Party)

  4. bc says:

    Growth in Vegas will not stop until folks do not want to live there anymore. You can implement a building moratorium and you will either end up with a dead city or real estate costs that are through the roof, San Francisco style. Myself, after living there in the 70s and 90s, I will never live in Las Vegas again with the lack of ability to have a green yard. My preference only, others will feel differently.

  5. Generous Welfare benefits and Open Border Immigration policy will drive them here to seek the good life, regardless of green front yards…

  6. […] figures in the USGS study also add precision underpinning to a ruling a year ago by Senior Judge Robert Estes who called the water authority’s plans for the water transfer […]

  7. […] figures in the USGS study also add precision underpinning to a ruling a year ago by Senior Judge Robert Estes who called the water authority’s plans for the water transfer […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s